Scuba Diving

SCUBA DIVING NEWS   ::   SCUBALINX   ::   SCUBA FORUM   ::   SCUBA POLL   ::   CYBER DIVER

Scuba Diving NewsScuba Diving CDNNScuba NewsScuba Diving Travel NewsScuba Diving Safety NewsEco NewsScuba Industry NewsScience

Dive News :: CDNNScuba Diving NewslettersCDNN Act NowCDNN Scuba Diving News PhotosScuba Diver AlertCDNN Scuba InterviewCDNN Scuba Diving Special ReportCDNN Scuba EditorialsCDNN Scuba Diving ArticlesScuba Diving Destinations

SCUBA DIVING PAGE ONE :: WORLD NEWS :: INDUSTRY

Suspected scuba killer: 'I did the best I could'

October 20, 2009

TORTOLA, British Virgin Islands — United States citizen David Swain who is accused of murdering his wife Shelley Tyre said that he did everything within his capabilities to save her once she was brought to the surface.

During Tuesday's sitting, the Court heard two video depositions – one lasting four hours and the other 20 minutes – during which Swain was interviewed by the Tyre's lawyer in 2004.

Swain, who has several years of training as an Emergency Medical Technician (EMT), said he tried whatever he could have for two to three minutes.

The deposition was the last evidence given by the Prosecution as they closed their case against Swain.

"I did the best I could…We were a long way from help and nothing left there for us to work with. I did what I could and that the conclusion was that she was gone from us," Swain said in the 2004 deposition. He also stated that he could not recall the exact sequence of the event since it occurred four years earlier.

Tyre and Swain were vacationing in the BVI with Christian and Bernice Thwaites along with their nine-year-old son. On March 12, 1999 the tourists went to explore the "the tugs" – a popular dive site between Cooper and Salt Island. Tyre and Swain dived first, but after about 40 minutes, Swain resurfaced without his wife. Tyre was later fished off the sea bed by Christian Thwaites.

In his testimony earlier in the trial, Christian Thwaites claimed that Swain performed chest compressions and mouth to mouth resuscitations for approximately 10 seconds. However, the defence produced a letter that Christian wrote to the Professional Association of Dive Instructors (PADI) which he claimed that both he and Swain performed CPR for about five minutes.

Swain in the deposition also said that he could not tell how long Tyre was without oxygen. "I am telling you it was a while - it could be 10 minutes or half an hour," Swain said.

Swain stated that he and Tyre had a conversation that they would have stayed together until they get where they wanted to go and then she would go off and do her survey and he would go and take his pictures.

He said that he last saw his wife at the two wrecked tugs on the sea bed. He also said that as usual they both checked their equipment before entering the water, which he said was generic pre-dive things that would normally be done.

"To this day I am not aware that anything was wrong with her mask or snorkel," Swain said in 2004.

He said that he had a vague recollection seeing his wife near the wrecks when he swam off in an easternly direction towards the reef. Swain said when he looked back he saw Shelley for sure and everything seemed normal and there was nothing to cause alarm. During the interview, Swain could not recall if he told Shelley that he was leaving or could he recall which direction she went.

Meanwhile, Swain said that he began an intimate relationship with Mary Basler sometime in June or July in 1999 following his wife's death.

He also shut down claims that he was upset with Tyre's decision to change jobs. He said their happiness was not based on money.

On Wednesday morning Swain's Lawyers Hayden Sinclair Douglas and Patrick Thompson will present their case to jurors by calling several witnesses.

 

David Swain flying high
David Swain on trial for murder
Former PADI 5-star dive shop owner, David Swain (above photo) "traveled very lavishly and extravagantly" after inheriting $630,000 from his wife, who died while the couple was scuba diving in the British Virgin Islands.  Swain (below photo) on October 7 being escorted into a courtroom in handcuffs for the start of his murder trial.

 

CDNN RELATED NEWS

  • BVI - PADI dive shop owner on trial for murdering wife to take stand
  • BVI - Murder trial: PADI 5-star dive shop owner got $630K after wife's death
  • BRITISH VIRGIN ISLANDS - Swain's wife stopped breathing 8 mins into dive
  • BVI - Murder trial: Woman details 'fling' with suspected scuba killer
  • BRITISH VIRGIN ISLANDS - Murder trial begins for former PADI dive shop owner
  • RHODE ISLAND - Accused wife killer's dive shop could become housing complex
  • BRITISH VIRGIN ISLANDS - Dive shop owner murder trial delayed again
  • BRITISH VIRGIN ISLANDS - Scuba murder trial delayed
  • TORTOLA - Murder trial of former PADI dive shop owner postponed
  • TORTOLA - Arraignment delayed for dive shop owner accused of scuba murder
  • TORTOLA - Friends, family rally to support scuba murder suspect David Swain
  • TORTOLA - Former PADI dive shop owner to be tried for scuba murder
  • RHODE ISLAND - New trial denied for dive shop owner accused of killing his wife
  • RHODE ISLAND - Dive shop owner's lawyer asks judges to dismiss murder conviction
  • TORTOLA - PADI dive shop owner charged with murder
  • RHODE ISLAND - Dive shop owner Swain waives extradition on murder charge
  • RHODE ISLAND - PADI dive shop owner accused of murder may waive extradition
  • RHODE ISLAND - Swain faces extradition hearing
  • RHODE ISLAND - Now it's a murder case: Swain arrested at his dive shop
  • RHODE ISLAND - Former PADI 5-star dive shop owner arrested on murder charge
  • RHODE ISLAND - PADI 5-star IDC owner appeals wrongful death verdict
  • TORTOLA - Police request evidence from Swain case
  • RHODE ISLAND - Swain bankrupt but still must pay $4.8 million
  • TORTOLA - Police to consider Swain verdict
  • RHODE ISLAND - Verdict: PADI dive shop owner murdered wife while scuba diving
  • RHODE ISLAND - PADI dive shop owner got away with murder in BVI says attorney
  • RHODE ISLAND - Grand story but untrue says dive shop owner accused of killing wife
  • RHODE ISLAND - PADI dive shop owner Swain could take witness stand today
  • RHODE ISLAND - PADI dive shop owner admits he did not use CPR on wife
  • RHODE ISLAND - Woman testifies Swain made romantic advances before wife died
  • RHODE ISLAND - Swain busted for breaking law as town council member
  • RHODE ISLAND - Swain's wife's death 'homicidal drowning' says medical examiner
  • RHODE ISLAND - PADI dive shop owner 'jovial' one day after wife's death in BVI
  • RHODE ISLAND - PADI dive shop owner accused of murdering wife racked up debts
  • RHODE ISLAND - Ocean State Scuba owner on trial for allegedly killing wife in Tortola
  • SCUBA FORUM

  • HAVE YOUR SAY - Discuss this article
  • KNOW BEFORE YOU GO

  • SCUBALINX :: Dive Virgin Islands
  • CYBER DIVER TRAVEL GUIDE :: USVI
  • CYBER DIVER TRAVEL GUIDE :: BVI
  • CDNN DESTINATIONS :: Virgin Islands
  • ScubaLinx Scuba Diving Directory

    SOURCE - BVI Platinum News

     

    Scuba Diving

    CDNN TOP NEWS STORIES

     

     

       ADVANCED SEARCH

    site map         ::         notice         ::         privacy         ::         about us         ::         faq         ::         my news         ::         advertise         ::         contact

    © 1995 - 2009  CYBER DIVER DIGITAL MEDIA NETWORK