Scuba Diving

SCUBA DIVING NEWS   ::   SCUBALINX   ::   SCUBA FORUM   ::   SCUBA POLL   ::   CYBER DIVER

Scuba Diving NewsScuba Diving CDNNScuba NewsScuba Diving Travel NewsScuba Diving Safety NewsEco NewsScuba Industry NewsScience

Dive News :: CDNNScuba Diving NewslettersCDNN Act NowCDNN Scuba Diving News PhotosScuba Diver AlertCDNN Scuba InterviewCDNN Scuba Diving Special ReportCDNN Scuba EditorialsCDNN Scuba Diving ArticlesScuba Diving Destinations

SCUBA DIVING PAGE ONE :: WORLD NEWS :: SAFETY

Great White Adventures shark cage diving accident nearly kills two divers

December 8, 2008

GUADALUPE ISLAND, Mexico — Two divers were rescued after a shark ripped off the side of a tourist boat shark feeding cage at Guadalupe Island in Mexico.

The crew of the MV Searcher, a San Diego-based liveaboard owned by Great White Adventures, managed to pull the divers to safety after a great white shark entered the cage and ripped off one of its side panels.

Environmentalists and legitimate shark scientists condemn shark feeding and shark baiting, a multi-million dollar tourism industry that exploits and damages sharks for thrill seeking tourists and self-aggrandizing underwater photographers who sell "sensational" shark photos and videos that disrespect and misrepresent sharks as chummed and manipulated television entertainment fodder.

San Diego-based Great White Adventures, also known as Shark Diving International,  and other shark feeders deliberately downplay the lucrative business of selling thrills to tourists and describe themselves as "shark conservationists" and "educators".

Shark experts dismiss such claims as blatant greenwash by profiteers who actually put sharks at greater risk by damaging their instinctive wariness of humans.

George Burgess, director of the International Shark Attack File at the University of Florida, questions the conservation value of viewing sharks that have been virtually programmed to tolerate people.

"What you're essentially seeing is an underwater circus. It's like seeing tigers jump through hoops," Burgess said. "I don't buy the argument that this is making converts for sharks. What it is is putting money in the bank by making people come to your boat instead of someone else's."

In February 2008, a tourist died after he was attacked by a baited shark while diving with Jim Abernethy Scuba Adventures, a notorious Florida-based shark feeding profiteer who takes thrill-seeking tourists to the Bahamas.

To avoid prosecution for running a business that systematically abuses marine wildlife and endangers humans, Abernethy moved his shark baiting tours offshore after shark feeding was banned in Florida in January 2002.

Within six months, shark feeding was also banned in Hawaii and the Cayman Islands.

Bad for sharks, bad for people

Most scientists who study sharks condemn DEMA, PADI, Scuba Diving Magazine and scores of sleazy, underwater image touts who collude to green-wash the lucrative business of shark baiting and prevent full protection of sharks and other endangered marine species.

Dr. Denise Herzing, a renowned marine mammalogist who conducts research in the Bahamas says feeding sharks is bad for people and sharks.

''Feeding the sharks changes their behavior,'' Herzing said. "It's just like feeding bears at Yellowstone. It makes them associate humans with food. It makes them more aggressive. It endangers people.''

Dr. Burgess says there have been more than two dozen injuries involving shark-feeding dives.

He opposes all shark feeding, not because of the danger but because it trains sharks to expect food from people and not to fear them.

He said: "They lose their natural caution around human beings. For the same reason on land, you don't feed alligators or bears. It's changing the behaviour of sharks and the ecology by concentrating sharks in one area."

 

Great White Adventures manipulates sharks with bait
Baited shark enters Great White Adventures cage
Side panel of Great White Adventures cage ripped off by shark
Shark feeding dive tour operators use bait to modify shark behavior (above photo) and maximize profits by selling guaranteed shark encounters for thrill seeking tourists who pay to view them from cages.  In a near-fatal shark feeding accident at Guadalupe Island, a baited shark entered the Great White Adventures cage (middle) and tore off the side panel, which may have injured the shark and certainly left the divers unprotected (below). Scientific studies confirm that feeding and baiting sharks is bad for both sharks and humans, and authorities have banned it in many parts of the world including Florida, Hawaii, the Cayman Islands, the Maldives and the Red Sea.

 

CDNN RELATED NEWS

  • CDNN SPECIAL REPORT - Shark Feeding
  • FLORIDA - Thrilled to death: Shark feeding in the Bahamas
  • FLORIDA - Jim Abernethy under criminal investigation for shark feeding death
  • BAHAMAS - Shark kills tourist during Jim Abernethy's 'interactive' shark feeding dive
  • FLORIDA - Fatal shark attack vindicates Florida's decision to ban shark feeding
  • BAHAMAS - Shark kills tourist during Jim Abernethy's 'interactive' shark feeding dive
  • KEY LARGO - Shark 1, shark molesting scuba idiot 0
  • FLORIDA - Utah tourist dies scuba diving with Jim Abernethy Scuba Adventures
  • GRAND BAHAMA - Shark attack victim sues Our Lucaya resort for $25m
  • WALKER'S CAY - Shark feeder Eric Ritter attacked at shark feeding site
  • SCUBA FORUM

  • HAVE YOUR SAY - Discuss this article
  • KNOW BEFORE YOU GO

  • SCUBALINX :: Dive Mexico
  • CDNN DESTINATIONS :: Mexico
  • CYBER DIVER TRAVEL :: Cozumel
  • Shark Feeding Timeline

    ScubaLinx Scuba Diving Directory

    © CDNN - CYBER DIVER NEWS NETWORK

     

    SHARK BAITING: Hype vs Reality

    Sharks: Bad Rap vs Reality

    Myth: Shark feeders and shark baiters aim to conserve sharks.

    Truth: Dive industry-endorsed shark feeders and shark baiters aim to profit from so-called "interactive" shark feeding tours that harm marine wildlife and compromise public safety.

    Myth: Shark feeding is a non-issue because shark finning is worse.

    Truth: Just because there are people doing worse things to sharks does not make shark feeding trivial, or a non-issue.

    Myth: Baiting sharks or feeding sharks does not modify shark behavior.

    Truth: Manipulating sharks with bait to approach dive boats and "perform" for a dozen or more thrill-seeking scuba diving tourists, or "model" for underwater photographers, severely damages their natural defense mechanisms and significantly increases the probability they will be killed by shark fishers.

    Myth: Feeding or baiting sharks is the solution to finning sharks.

    Truth: There is no evidence that the billion plus consumers who eat sharks are motivated by hatred, fear and revenge, nor that rebranding sharks as "circus" or "rodeo" performers will make them less appetizing. Since the dive industry endorsed "interactive" shark diving, the number of sharks killed every year has tripled to satisfy the increasing Chinese demand for shark fin soup.

    Myth: People get their information about sharks from Hollywood horror movies.

    Truth: Most people do not get their information about sharks from crude, dated Hollywood horror movies (JAWS) nor underwater image touts masquerading as conservationists.  While it is natural to fear apex predators such as bears, lions, tigers and sharks, it is not natural to wish them to be wiped off the face of the planet. People understand that most big animal species are threatened by human activities and should be protected.

    Myth: Pretending that sharks do not eat humans will help protect them.

    Truth: Whale sharks are renowned as the gentle giants of the shark world.  They do not eat humans, yet they are among the most endangered of all shark species. While not the perferred main course of apex predators, the notion that humans are somehow exempt from the menu is almost as absurd as the notion that encouraging people to bait, feed, poke, prod and ride sharks will stop one billion plus people from eating them.

     

       ADVANCED SEARCH

    site map         ::         notice         ::         privacy         ::         about us         ::         faq         ::         my news         ::         advertise         ::         contact

    © 1995 - 2009  CYBER DIVER DIGITAL MEDIA NETWORK